[RPi4] Pimoroni Fan Shim

  • Just a humble question:

    As the RPi is designed to work (mostly) without any heatsink, why should it be equipped with a complicated cooling system? A simple, quiet, passive heatsink isn't enough?

  • I'm use my RPi4B with a "homemade" passive aluminium heatsink for the last two years. No heat issue.
    I looked at that "Pimoroni Fan SHIM"project, without metal heatsink to spread the heat, I think is no more than a fancy, less effective toy. But this is only my humble opinion, after three decades work in electronic industry... Your RPi, your choice.

  • Right back at you, friend!

    I’m choosing to believe Pimoroni marketing - if their little fan and a script to manage it keeps the Pi anywhere near 30c, I know it will continue functioning as intended long past its intended useful life/MTBF (you mentioned fan noise in an earlier post - not a great concern of mine)

  • Yeah, me, again, last time, I swear. :)

    "I’m choosing to believe Pimoroni marketing" - just two last things about this:
    1. "They never produce what you need, produce what they can sell."
    2. Did you ever seen somewhere else a processor to be cooled just with a fan? Without a heatsink? I didn't, and I seen a several of PC, laptop, STB's and others from inside...

  • See, you missed the word marketing. I fully acknowledged I was being sold to, and accepted it. If that little bit of airflow helps me squeeze the last 0.01% of that machine’s capability or lifespan, it will have been worth it to me

  • RPi4/5 are designed to run far hotter than people are used to, or comfortable with. As long as you are using 'some' kind of cooling solution it will be fine. If you like fan noise, go nuts. If you prefer a passive solution that will be fine too.

  • Any fan noise is primarily blocked by being behind my display (a plasma with fans of its own), and quite easily masked by my audio system, the latter being surely the case for the majority of users.