3D issue / left/right not properly aligned (S905 & S905x)

4LTJ · December 5, 2016 at 7:16 AM

First of all, a friendly hello to all LibreELEC user - I'm the new guy
Really love my S905 and S905X boxes - an THANK YOU so much kszaq for your incredible work !

Now to those 3D issues I encountered while testing all features with the box.
- When starting a 3D bluray.iso (tested with self-ripped movies: pets, startrek beyond and turtles - full menu) LibreELEC says "3D disabled" and starts the movie as Over-Under.
- then switching the TV seperately to 3D (ou) the upper and lower pictures doen't match in alignment. (see screens)

So far I can tell, is that LibreELEC doens't recognize the source-material to be 3D, because the menu get's "split" in TV 3D_over/under mode.
Tested other 3D over/under movies (.mkv) --> all work fine ! Don't have the ability to test another 3D TV
Both boxes (the s905 & s905x) show this issue.

My setup:
UE55ES6100 (TV<-->Onkyo TX-NR656 <--> non-ARC hdmi port, CEC disabled)
MXQ Pro 4K (s905) and Seguro X4 (s905x) (tried several devicetrees on the mxq)
KSZAQ libreELEC for S905/S905X (v 7.0.2.009, also earlier ones)
Quality HDMI cables no really good ones...

Any hints to address this info?? -.-

**kszaq** · December 6, 2016 at 9:14 AM

Thank you for detailed report. For completeness, please also enable debugging in Kodi and post a log according to this post: LibreELEC

I marked that thread with "bug" icon to remember to look into it but I can't promise much as I don't have a 3D TV. As far as I can tell this is a known issue...

4LTJ · December 7, 2016 at 2:15 PM

- will test it today with another 3D TV (Panasonic Viera, 4k,...)

- on sunday I will gather the debug output

Thank you sooo much - you are really doing a great work for so many !

4LTJ · log-2016-12-10-09.33.30.zip

Here you have the LOGFILES from my:

S905 - clean install - running 7.0.2.009

When starting the bluray.iso it asks wheter to start playback in --> 3D Mode --> same as movie --> TV switches automatically to 3D --> result is the issue described in first post.

4K and 3D an Panasonic will follow on sunday

4LTJ · December 17, 2016 at 9:52 AM

UPDATE:

- tested it with other TVs (Panasonic 4k / Samsung fullHD) -- same effect / bug !

- tested it with other 3D movie files and found something NEW!

I loaded up a "movie_3d.mkv" which was 1080p side-by-side.
LibreElec detected it was 3D (however it did it)
same effect on SBS movies !
==> the RIGHT & LEFT borders are not aligned properly.

When playing the "movie_3d.mkv" with my TV's built-in Mediaplayer it works fine : so it's rather a software bug, I guess ?!

4LTJ · December 28, 2016 at 11:03 AM

*push*

as said, maybe this is an issue in LE itself, and not AML-chipset related